| Year | Player(s) |
|---|---|
| 2012 | Chipper Jones, 3B; Craig Kimbrel, P; Dan Uggla, 2B; Michael Bourn, OF |
| 2011 | Brian McCann, C; Chipper Jones, 3B; Craig Kimbrel, P; Jonny Venters, P; Jair Jurrjens, P |
| 2010 | Brian McCann, C; Martin Prado, 2B; Tim Hudson, P; Omar Infante, 3B; Jason Heyward, OF |
| 2009 | Brian McCann, C |
| 2008 | Brian McCann, C; Chipper Jones, 3B |
| 2007 | Brian McCann, C;John Smoltz, P |
| 2006 | Andruw Jones, OF; Brian McCann, C; Edgar Renteria, SS |
| 2005 | Andruw Jones, OF; John Smoltz, P |
| 2004 | Johnny Estrada, C |
| 2003 | Rafael Furcal, SS; Marcus Giles, OF; Andruw Jones, OF; Javy Lopez, C; Russ Ortiz, P; Gary Sheffield, OF; John Smoltz, P |
| 2002 | Tom Glavine, P; Andruw Jones, OF; Mike Remlinger, P; John Smoltz, P |
| 2001 | John Burkett, P; Chipper Jones, 3B |
| 2000 | Andres Galarraga, 1B; Tom Glavine, P; Andruw Jones, OF; Chipper Jones, 3B; Greg Maddux, P |
| 1999 | Brian Jordan, OF; Kevin Millwood, P |
| 1998 | Andres Galarraga, 1B; Tom Glavine, P; Chipper Jones, 3B; Javy Lopez, C; Greg Maddux, P; Walt Weiss, SS |
| 1997 | Jeff Blauser, SS; Tom Glavine, P; Chipper Jones, 3B; Kenny Lofton, OF; Javy Lopez, C; Greg Maddux, P; Denny Neagle, P |
| 1996 | Tom Glavine, P; Chipper Jones, 3B; Greg Maddux, P; Fred McGriff, 1B; John Smoltz, P; Mark Wohlers, P |
| 1995 | Greg Maddux, P; Fred McGriff, 1B |
| 1994 | David Justice, OF; Greg Maddux, P; Fred McGriff, 1B |
| 1993 | Steve Avery, P; Tom Glavine, P; John Smoltz, P; Jeff Blauser, SS; David Justice, OF |
| 1992 | Tom Glavine, P; John Smoltz, P; Terry Pendleton, 3B; Ron Gant, OF |
| 1991 | Tom Glavine, P |
| 1990 | Greg Olson, C |
| 1989 | John Smoltz, P |
| 1988 | Gerald Perry, 1B |
| 1987 | Dale Murphy, OF; Ozzie Virgil, C |
| 1986 | Dale Murphy, OF |
| 1985 | Dale Murphy, OF |
| 1984 | Dale Murphy, OF; Rafael Ramirez, SS; Claudell Washington, OF |
| 1983 | Bruce Benedict, C; Glenn Hubbard, 2B; Dale Murphy, OF; Pascual Perez, P |
| 1982 | Bob Horner, 3B; Dale Murphy, OF; Phil Niekro, P |
| 1981 | Bruce Benedict, C |
| 1980 | Dale Murphy, OF |
| 1977 | Gary Matthews, OF |
| 1978 | Jeff Burroughs, OF; Phil Niekro, P; Biff Pocoroba, C |
| 1977 | Willie Montanez, 1B |
| 1976 | Andy Messersmith, P; Dick Ruthven, P |
| 1975 | Phil Niekro, P |
| 1974 | Henry Aaron, OF; Ralph Garr, OF; Buzz Capra, P |
| 1973 | Henry Aaron, OF; Darrell Evans, 3B; Davey Johnson, 2B |
| 1972 | Henry Aaron, OF |
| 1971 | Henry Aaron, OF; Felix Millan, 2B |
| 1970 | Henry Aaron, OF; Rico Carty, OF; Felix Millan, 2B; Hoyt Wilhelm, P |
| 1969 | Henry Aaron, OF; Felix Millan, 2B; Phil Niekro, P |
| 1968 | Henry Aaron, OF; Felipe Alou, OF; Ron Reed, P |
| 1967 | Henry Aaron, OF; Joe Torre, C; Denver Lemaster, P |
| 1964 | Henry Aaron, OF; Felipe Alou, OF; Joe Torre, C |
| 1965 | Henry Aaron, OF; Joe Torre, C |
| 1964 | Henry Aaron, OF; Joe Torre, C |
| 1963 | Henry Aaron, OF; Warren Spahn, P; Joe Torre, C |
| 1962 | Henry Aaron, OF; Frank Bolling, 2B; Del Crandall, C; Bob Shaw, P; Warren Spahn, P; Second-game additions: Henry Aaron, OF (injured first game); Eddie Mathews, 3B |
| 1961 | Henry Aaron, OF; Frank Bolling, 2B; Eddie Mathews, 3B; Warren Spahn, P |
| 1960 | Henry Aaron, OF; Joe Adcock, 1B; Bob Buhl, P; Del Crandall, C; Eddie Mathews, 3B |
| 1959 | Henry Aaron, OF; Lew Burdette, P; Del Crandall, C; Eddie Mathews, 3B; Warren Spahn, P Johnny Logan, SS (second-game addition) |
| 1958 | Henry Aaron, OF; Del Crandall, C; Johnny Logan, SS; Eddie Mathews, 3B; Don McMahon, P; Warren Spahn, P |
| 1957 | Henry Aaron, OF; Lew Burdette, P; Johnny Logan, SS; Eddie Mathews, 3B; Red Schoendienst, 2B; Warren Spahn, P |
| 1956 | Henry Aaron, OF; Del Crandall, C; Eddie Mathews, 3B; Warren Spahn, P |
| 1955 | Henry Aaron, OF; Gene Conley, P; Del Crandall, C; Johnny Logan, SS; Eddie Mathews, 3B |
| 1954 | Gene Conley, P; Jim Wilson, P; Del Crandall, C; Warren Spahn, P |
| 1953 | Del Crandall, C; Eddie Mathews, 3B; Warren Spahn, P |
| 1952 | Warren Spahn, P |
| 1951 | Bob Elliott, 3B; Warren Spahn, P |
| 1950 | Walker Cooper, C; Warren Spahn, P |
| 1949 | Vern Bickford, P; Warren Spahn, P |
| 1948 | Bob Elliott, 3B; Tommy Holmes, OF; Phil Masi, C; Johnny Sain, P; Eddie Stanky, 2B |
| 1947 | Bob Elliott, 3B; Phil Masi, C; Johnny Sain, P; Warren Spahn, P |
| 1946 | Mort Cooper, P; Johnny Hopp, OF; Phil Masi, C |
| 1945 | No game held |
| 1944 | Nate Andrews, P; Al Javery, P; Connie Ryan, 2B |
| 1943 | Al Javery, P |
| 1942 | Ernie Lombardi, C; Eddie Miller, SS |
| 1941 | Eddie Miller, SS |
| 1940 | Max West, OF |
| 1939 | Lou Fette, P |
| 1938 | Tony Cuccinello, 2B; Jim Turner, P |
| 1937 | Gene Moore, OF |
| 1936 | Wally Berger, OF |
| 1935 | Wally Berger, OF |
| 1934 | Wally Berger, OF; Fred Frankhouse, P |
| 1933 | Wally Berger, OF |